• Home
  • About Us
    • Our History & Accomplishments
    • Our Leader
    • LMA Gives
    • Photo Gallery
    • Library & Resources
  • Services
    • Assignment of Benefits & Insurance Litigation
    • Associations & Nonprofits
    • Business Development & Procurement
    • Education
    • Energy & Environment
    • Emergency Management
    • Flood Insurance & Resilience
    • Healthcare
    • Insurance/Financial Services
    • Legislative & Regulatory Monitoring
    • Marketing Intelligence
    • Property & Casualty Insurance
    • Public Relations
  • News / Podcasts / Library
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our History & Accomplishments
    • Our Leader
    • LMA Gives
    • Photo Gallery
    • Library & Resources
  • Services
    • Assignment of Benefits & Insurance Litigation
    • Associations & Nonprofits
    • Business Development & Procurement
    • Education
    • Energy & Environment
    • Emergency Management
    • Flood Insurance & Resilience
    • Healthcare
    • Insurance/Financial Services
    • Legislative & Regulatory Monitoring
    • Marketing Intelligence
    • Property & Casualty Insurance
    • Public Relations
  • News / Podcasts / Library
  • Contact
  • MENU

A $442,000 Attorney Fee in a $25,000 Settlement?

SHARE THIS

Florida appellate court says no!

We’ve chronicled in these pages one of the factors involved in weakening Florida’s property insurance market: attorney fees, especially the misuse of the contingency fee multiplier by plaintiff attorneys.  Another example has come to light in a recent opinion by Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal in Miami.  This should be a must-read for defense counsel.

A disputed water damage claim ended in a $25,000 settlement by the insurance company with the homeowner.  The only thing left to settle was attorney fees.  A Miami-Dade Circuit court had agreed with the homeowners attorney’s figuring and awarded a lodestar amount (billable hours x reasonable hourly rate) of $209,300 in attorney and paralegal fees.  The court then applied a fee multiplier of 2, added another $12,500 in costs and $13,800 for the plaintiff’s expert, for a total award of just under $442,000.

The insurance company had objected, saying in part that the number of billable hours should be reduced from 469 to 101, given it was a settlement without trial and with minimal discovery and depositions.  The Third District Court of Appeal (DCA) agreed and in its opinion, Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company vs. Raghunath Deshpande, reversed the trial court’s decision, calling the fees “excessive and unsupported by the evidence.”  It sent the case back to circuit court for a rework.

“We do not… affirm the lodestar amount because the record does not contain competent, substantial evidence that 469 hours were reasonably expended in this case,” the opinion stated.  The DCA referenced “notorious ‘billable hours’ syndrome, with its multiple evils of exaggeration, duplication, and invention.”  It also reversed the trial court’s application of the fee multiplier, stating “the record is devoid of any evidence that the relevant market required a contingency fee multiplier to obtain competent counsel.”

This case is one of several we’ve seen recently in Florida with inappropriate attorney fee awards (see our backgrounder How a $41,000 Plumbing Leak Turned Into a $1.2 Million Attorney Fee.)  This DCA opinion is worth reading for the loosey-goosey way some requests for attorney fees are put together and for the relevant case law it so aptly references, including past abuses.

We believe that the 3rd DCA used reasonableness and common sense to reverse the trial court’s attorney fee award.  In our opinion, there are three reasons to file a motion with the court – to educate, advocate, or capitulate.  This order underscores that the appeals court judges have been educated!

LMA Newsletter of 11-30-20

SHARE THIS

Tags: Attorney Fees, Contingency Fee Multiplier, Insurance Litigation, Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company vs. Raghunath Deshpande

“Just a quick note to let you know how much I have appreciated your newsletter over the years and the assistance they offer for those in the field of claims. We depend on the information more than you will ever know!”

Laurie Rasberry, Chief Claims Officer
Acorn Claims
Prosper, Texas

“Just wanted to say that I thoroughly love your newsletter. It’s is always informative and insightful to the ins and outs of our industry.  You are an inspiration and an important asset in the insurance world.  Keep up the great work!” 

Cynthia Scott, President
University Insurance Group
Davie, FL

“Great article on Risk Rating 2.0!”

Austin Perez, Senior Policy Representative for Federal Housing, Valuation, Insurance and Commercial Issues
National Association of Realtors
Washington, D.C.

“Another great Newsletter on Florida industry this week.  Your service and advocacy in Florida is very important to keeping me updated and apprised of the Florida insurance laws, trends and overall environment.  Something similar is very much needed in Louisiana, too.”

Jennifer Tedesco, Esq., Claims Director
Pharos Claims Services
Orlando, FL

“I have followed your weekly newsletter and podcasts and now have a full appreciation for what you bring to this industry.  You are an inspiring force, plain and simple.  I wanted you to know that you make a difference.  Thank you for all you do!”

Jeffrey Karam, CPCU
Bradenton, FL

“Lisa this is another great newsletter, and we appreciate the time and energy you put into these informative updates – you are on top of these topics!”

Mike Graham, CEO
Smart Vent Products, Floodproofing.com, & Risk Reduction Plus
Juno Beach, FL

“Thank you Lisa for staying on top of, as well as advocating, for Florida residents and legislative reform. Your newsletters are very informative and enjoy reading the points of view.”  

Shawna Miller, Sr. Claims Quality Assurance & Compliance Manager
Florida Peninsula Insurance Company
Jacksonville, FL

“Lisa Miller is a true champion for the insurance industry, with her regular updates! We appreciate all you do and keeping us up to date on priority issues!”

Gillian Lloyd, Account Executive
Zywave
Milwaukee, WI

“Your newsletter is fabulous!  I greatly appreciate the topics you expose, so that insurance professionals like myself can keep up with the latest events that affect the public we serve and ourselves.”

Cynthia Hoehn, Independent Property & Casualty Personal Lines insurance agent
Clermont, FL

GET THE LATEST UPDATES IN YOUR INBOX FOR FREE!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

READ THE LATEST LMA NEWSLETTER ONLINE NOW

READ NOW

331 N. Monroe Street
Tallahassee, FL 32301
(850) 222-1041
[email protected]

*DBE certified through affiliate Lisa Miller Consultants

© Copyright 2008 - 2023
Lisa Miller Associates
All Rights Reserved
Managed by SiteBolts